G.P. FARINÓS, M. De la POZA, P.
HERNÁNDEZ-CRESPO, F. ORTEGO and P. CASTAÑERA
CSIC, CIB, Dpto Biología de Plantas,
Velázquez 144, 28006, Madrid, Spain
The greater specificity of Cry1Ab toxin
with respect to conventional insecticides to control corn borers, and the
likely reduction of the latter under a transgenic crop system should result
in a more favourable environment for the non target-arthropods in the crop.
However, it has been reported from laboratory experiments that Bt-maize
may have a negative impact on some natural enemies by a combined effect
of Bt exposure and nutritional deficiency caused by a reduction in the
quantity and quality of their food supply. Laboratory experiments are very
useful to point out possible deleterious effects of Bt-maize, but they
must be verified with field experiments.
In 2000 we have started a three years
field-study to assess, in a commercial field (about 5 ha) near Madrid (Spain),
the potential impact of Bt-maize on the abundance and diversity of non-target
arthropods. Three treatments with three replicates (= 0.6 ha/plot) were
arranged in a completely randomised block design: Bt-maize (cv. Compa CB)
was compared with the isogenic cv. Dracma under conventional farm practices,
with or without Imidacloprid treatment. Two sampling techniques (visual
counts and pitfall traps) were used to compare their effects on non-target
arthropods that comprise maize-based food webs from late June to the end
of September.
Visual surveys reveal that Orius
spp. and spiders were the most abundant predators on the maize plants.
A common pattern of the frequency of Orius on plants was found in
both years, with few specimens at the beginning of the summer and a big
increase in September. Conversely, spiders were present in the plant all
through the summer.
Ground beetles and spiders were the most
abundant poliphagous predators found in pitfall traps in all treatments.
Five carabid species accounted for 98% of the total beetles collected.
Similarly, six species of spiders accounted for 97% of their total number.
No detrimental effects associated with
the transgenic cultivars have been detected so far, although no firm conclusions
can be drawn until these studies are completed.